The Best Diaper Pail in 2021 – Comparison, Guide and Reviews

Quality:
Efficiency:
Design:
Price:

The Ubbi Steel is undeniably more expensive than the average diaper pails, but it doesn’t resort to dedicated refills and can create long-term savings. In addition, it does not require any concessions from you and blocks odors. As soon as you have the budget, we recommend it without hesitation.

See Price on Amazon

See Price on Amazon

This product is compact, which implies almost mechanically concessions on its capacity: count up to 25 newborn diapers. That is why it is undoubtedly more suitable for family members, or to equip a bathroom, than as a main diaper pail.

Note that the refills offer quite a good capacity: up to 300 newborn diapers each. Rest assured, no need to change the bag each time: a blade, included in the door and perfectly secure to prevent children from injuring themselves, allows you to cut and retie the current one from below.

25 layers maximum before emptying so a good capacity. Contains good odors, and ergonomics level it is at the top. I can only recommend her because of this.

Thierry C.

When it comes to throwing away diapers, it’s easy: you have a pedal to lift the cover and a spring-loaded hatch. This can be especially ideal for grandparents who have some difficulty bending down or have joint pain.

The product is also equipped with many child safety devices: there is one for the flap and one for the door, in addition to the plastic end that covers the blade. Stress is thus effectively eliminated.

But besides stress, the other big enemy is smells. However, they are here well maintained inside. Indeed, the manufacture was not carried out in standard plastic, but in ABS plastic, more resistant, and rubber gaskets are also part.

Summary of Dekor Mini Specifications

• The best for the immediate family .
• Lightweight and space-saving, easy to move and store.
• Rubber and ABS plastic seals to trap odors.
• Door for emptying the trash, with blade fitted with child protection.
• Child safety devices for the door and spring-loaded hatch.
• Opening pedal.
• Layers before emptying  : 25 maximum.
• Diapers per refill  : approximately 300 newborn diapers.
• Dimensions  : 25.4 * 18.42 * 43.82cm / 10 * 7.25 * 17.25in.
• Weight  : 1.69 kg / 3.73 lb.

Advantages and Disadvantages of The Dekor Mini

Pros

• Very space-saving trash can
• Specific plastic against odors
• Lid opening pedal

Cons

• Limited capacity

Our Verdict on the Dekor Mini

Quality:
Efficiency:
Design:
Price:

The Dekor Mini is a model that we recommend to grandparents, uncles and aunts: they will be able to accommodate the little one who has just been born more easily without having to deal with an expensive and bulky model. For parents, the small capacity of the trash can seem somewhat limited.

See Price on Amazon

Dekor Plus Video Demonstration

What We Think of the Dekor Plus

The main advantage of this pail, the one that makes it the model suitable for ecological use, is the wide opening of the main hatch: 168 cm², or 23 in². This is significantly higher than what can be observed in the competition. Instead of the brand name refills, you can opt for a large bucket liner.

If you nevertheless choose to use this product with disposable diapers, the capacity remains very satisfactory: the trash can hold around 60 before having to be emptied, while the refills offer a capacity approaching 300.

The smells are well locked away that’s what matters to me. The quality is ok, and there are almost 300 layers before recharging so on this point it is strong, stronger than the others. I love.

Gislaine L.

The bag emptying is very simple: you cut the currently inserted refill using a blade protected by a plastic case, then you make a knot under the part still in the trash. You can also throw in a diaper without having to bend down: a pedal opens the flap.

The latter is also provided with child safety, just like the door. To avoid too much odor, ABS plastic was chosen as the main material and rubber gaskets are also present.

However, some drawbacks should be noted: some buyers report small problems with closing the cover. Others also point out that by investing a little more, we can obtain a steel model even more effective against bad smells.

Summary of Dekor Plus Specifications

• Best for using cloth diapers .
• Compatible with large reusable bucket liners.
• Wide opening to accommodate all types of diapers: 168 cm² / 26 in².
• Odors trapped by rubber and ABS plastic seals.
• Child safety devices for the blade, the door and the cover.
• Foot control pedal.
• Diapers before emptying  : up to a maximum of 60 newborn diapers.
• Layers per refill  : approximately 300.
• Dimensions  : 34.29 * 24.13 * 57.79cm / 13.5 * 9.5 * 22.75 in.
• Weight  : 3.82 kg / 8.42 lb.

 

Advantages and Disadvantages of the Dekor Plus

Pros

• Ideal for green parents
• Very well secured against children
• Easy to change and empty bags

Cons

• Price a bit high
• Very slightly lower quality

 

Our Verdict on The Dekor Plus

Quality:
Efficiency:
Design:
Price:

If you are considering use with disposable diapers, the Dekor Plus is not the model we recommend first. On the other hand, if you are going to use mainly cloth diapers, it seems to us to be the best option available for you on the market thanks to the large surface available to throw.

See Price on Amazon

See Price on Amazon

Tommee Tippee Simplee Video Demonstration

What we Think of the Tommee Tippee Simplee

Diaper pails are sometimes embellished with many frills that are not always as facilitating as they should in everyday use. None of that here: you take the diaper, you lift the lid, you throw it away.

While a few buyers regret this rudimentary side, many hail the fact that it saves you time. Rest assured, you still have essential items on the diaper pails, including the blade to cut the refills as you go.

A little heavy, but it’s okay. Easy to maintain and clean is the main thing for me, after quality follows so this is really what I expected from this diaper pail. So yes, 5 stars, even though sometimes some odors remain.

Caroline M.

However, here it is not placed in a door, but under the cover. We consider this position effective and safe, but still issue a caveat on the quality of the edge: it does not seem as effective as other models. Sometimes you have to make two attempts before you can successfully cut the bag.

We are much more enthusiastic about the protection offered against bacteria: thanks to a special film containing an antibacterial, 99% of them are eliminated. You prevent germs from spreading throughout the house.

You are looking at a space-saving, inexpensive product, and therefore made from standard plastic. As a result, odors are not retained as well as with some competing diaper pails. However, the difference with a conventional trash can remains very noticeable. It can accommodate up to approximately 18 diapers.

 

Summary of Tommee Tippee Simplee Specifications

• The best way to get rid of bacteria.
• About 99% of bacteria eliminated thanks to the antibacterial film.
• Compact size, blade inserted directly into the lid.
• 2 purchase options: with 1 or 4 refills.
• Layers before emptying: about 18.
• Layers per refill: approximately 180.
• Dimensions  : 29.5 * 25.7 * 41.7cm / 16.42 * 11.61 * 10.12 in.
• Weight  : 2.18 kg / 4.81 lb.

 

Advantages and Disadvantages of the Tommee Tippee Simplee

Pros

• Make sure to eliminate bacteria
• Rather accessible product and refills
• Easy to use every day.

Cons

• Quality of the recessed blade
• Limited odor trap

Our Verdict on the Tommee Tippee Simplee

Quality:
Efficiency:
Design:
Price:

The Tommee Tippee Simplee keeps its promises: it is easy to use every day and not expensive. In addition, its refills are also affordable. It doesn’t present the same level of quality or performance as the more expensive models but will satisfy parents who do not like taking the lead or the bacteria.

See Price on Amazon

See Price on Amazon

Besides the high purchase price of the Munchkin Step, what can make the most modest parents hesitate is the price of the refills: only those specific to the brand are compatible, and they are not cheap either. However, this price is not without justification, on the contrary.

First, you have the choice between two types of bags: classics, or ring models which are easier to empty and close. Then, all the refills offered by Munchkin are scented with lavender: even when taking out the trash, you do not have to put up with the foul smell.

The best for me. The others do not trap odors at this point, it quickly becomes foul. Here we really have no smell, so for once it’s 10 out of 10. I fully recommend !!

Manu E.

For even more in-depth odor control, this diaper pail is sold equipped with an Arm & Hammer deodorant disc, with the scent chosen again being lavender.

Finally, a patented system allows the bag to be twisted around itself when the cover is closed, which also helps to record the scents. However, this process comes with a slight drawback that should be noted: when the bag is soon full, it may be necessary to push a little on a diaper to make it fit.

Ease of use is essential. You get a pedal to lift the cover with your foot. A blade to cut the refills as they go is also present. It is not located directly in the door, but higher in the trash can. The height reinforces the safety of the product.

Summary of the characteristics of the Munchkin Step

• The most effective against bad odors.
• Lavender scented refills, 2 options: ring or classic.
• Arm & Hammer Deodorant Disc.
• Patented bag locking system.
• Blade located behind the door, at the top of the trash can.
• Foot pedal to open the cover with a simple press of the foot.
• Dimensions  : 33.02 * 31 * 70.1cm / 13 * 12.2 * 27.6in.
• Weight  : 4.74 kg / 10.45 lb.

Advantages and disadvantages of the Munchkin Step

Pros

• Traps odors very well
• 2 types of refills that can be used
• Very practical blade and pedal

Cons

• High price
• A little difficult to close when full

Our verdict on the Munchkin Step

Quality:
Efficiency:
Design:
Price:

The Munchkin Step is a high-end model. It can seem a bit expensive for parents who have to watch their finances. However, it has a significant advantage: you will hardly find better protection against odors. Even open lid, you don’t feel much.

Our opinion on the Safety 1 ^st Easy Saver

The alternative without refills
Safety 1st Easy Saver

The Safety 1 ^st Easy Saver attempts to offer a compromise between a traditional, less expensive pail and a diaper pail designed for easier handling and an increased possibility of combating bad odors. Cheap, it knows how to fulfill its role but will require some effort on your part.

Safety 1 ^st Easy Saver video demonstration

What we think of the Safety 1 ^st Easy Saver

Let’s start by presenting what is arguably the biggest plus point about this item: You use regular trash bags. It is therefore not necessary to spend a fortune on proprietary top-ups. If you need to save as much money as possible, this is a great option.

In addition, the build quality is satisfactory for the price. Even if we can, it is true, notice that the button which is used to open the lid, and is placed on the top of the trash can, sometimes lacks reactivity.

Really light and easy to maintain. We will say that it is a bit like the standard diaper pail. A bin that satisfies both in terms of quality and price. Very happy then.

Amandine G.

Here you are faced with a compact product, but where the available space is nevertheless satisfactory. You can put a lot of layers in it, but can you avoid the odors? Yes, on condition, of course, to put a little of yours in it.

Basic, an air freshener disc is included with your purchase. This indeed gives off a pleasant scent. But alone, he will struggle to fight against the smell of garbage can almost full of used diapers. Fortunately, the manufacturer was aware of this, so the disc is in a container where you can place baking soda.

It’s a simple and effective technique, you just have to think about it from time to time. We consider this diaper bin to be a very good product: it strikes a very fair balance between low cost and odor control. To get better, you will be forced to significantly increase your budget.

Summary of Safety 1 ^st Easy Saver Features

• The most universal .
• Affordable, space-saving and compatible with all trash bags.
• Deodorant disc included with your purchase.
• Presence of a container, possibility of adding baking soda.
• Button to open the cover.
• Dimensions  : 38.1 * 27.6 * 46.7cm / 15 * 18.4 * 10.87in.
• Weight  : 1.32 kg / 2.91 lb.

Advantages and Disadvantages of the Safety 1 ^st Easy Saver

Quality:
Efficiency:
Design:
Price:

With the Safety 1 ^st Easy Saver you are not dependent on a brand: you can buy normal pail bags. In addition, the use is simple. On the other hand, if you want to avoid bad smells, this product will require a little investment on your part: without help, it is not very effective in this regard.

Why Trust Us

All of the recommendations that we make on Achatlemeilleur.ca are the result of several weeks or months of research, tests, comparisons, analyzes of consumer opinions and, if necessary, interviews with experts and scientists. You will quickly realize that the products we recommend here are not the most expensive or the most trendy: they are the ones that will do their job best on a daily basis, passing all safety, reliability and efficiency tests with flying colors and with an interesting quality / price ratio for you.

Finally, the products we recommend are the ones we would like to buy, and the ones we would choose for our friends and family as well.

What to Know Before Buying a Diaper Pail

You may be wondering what the point of buying a diaper pail is. And what are the parameters you need to take into account to make the right choice. Here are some answers.

Bin and Diaper Bin/Pail, What’s The Difference?

It’s simple: diaper bins are designed to accommodate diapers only. Generally, therefore, they focus on fighting odors and bacteria, and are mostly designed to be used with baby in the arms. They save time and better sort your waste.

Is The Diaper Pail Suitable if I Have Joint Pain?

Absolutely! You should then prefer a pedal diaper pail, which will prevent you from bending down. They are also great tools to help older people who may need to take care of your child from time to time.

Can I Equip Myself With a Diaper Pail in a Small Space?

Having a pile of trash in a small space can quickly become unpleasant. But rest assured: there are compact models, which have the additional advantage of being generally offered at very reasonable prices.

Do Diaper Pails Eliminate Odors Permanently?

It’s a little different: they contain them. In other words, the odors are still present in the bag and on the diapers, but they are confined so as not to escape into the air of the house.

Our Selection Criteria for Buying a Diaper Pail

Now is the time to buy! Which diaper pail will you select? Without a doubt, the one that you think offers the best value for money in your budget. But how do you have a precise reference in mind? To do this, you have to compare the characteristics of each product. Here’s what to watch out for.

The price

Count around $ 30 to $ 40 for an entry-level or even intermediate model. Then you will find a number of great offers around $ 60. To take advantage of a high-end product that is very effective at trapping odors, it may be necessary to invest more, up to $ 90 or $ 100.

The Material

There are three main choices:

• “Standard” plastic: it can tend, over the long term, to soak up bad smells, and will be used for a single child.

• ABS plastic: it resists better, and absorbs less odors. It is an interesting intermediate option.

• Steel, treated with a powder: it confines odors and ensures foolproof strength.

Odor Control Processes

In addition to the material retained, there are other strategies to trap odors. The most common, which are found on a large number of models, are the following:

• The presence of rubber seals.

• A hatch under the cover.

We can also find, a little less often:

• A deodorant disc.

• A container, suitable, for example, for adding baking soda.

To determine actual effectiveness, we invite you to read product reviews and rely on buying guides: all manufacturers will tell you that odors are well contained, but in reality not all models are created equal.

The Charging Mode

There are two types of diaper pails:

• Those that work with normal trash bags.

• Those that work with proprietary refills.

The bags normal trash are cheaper but sometimes less spacious. In addition, they are generally less strong and more difficult to remove.

For proprietary refills, you have to look at several elements:

• The capacity of the refill: this is expressed in the number of layers (newborn size). It often fluctuates between 150 and 300.

• The scent of the refill: some refills are scented. It is a simple and very effective way to avoid bad odors.

• The type of refill: the classic bag format is the most common, but there are also refills equipped with a ring. It is then easier to close them and dispose of them.

• The price: find out about the price of refills before choosing your diaper pail, as it varies a lot from one manufacturer to another.

The Capacity

This is not always clearly indicated, but when it is, it is expressed in newborn size diapers. This is the number of layers the trash can hold before it needs to be emptied.

The Emptying Process

Most diaper pails have a blade, usually recessed in a door, or placed under the lid, and protected by plastic. This intervenes to empty the trash, the steps are as follows:

• You cut the refill, above the layers, with the blade.

• You tie a knot at the bottom of the part that remains in the trash.

• You continue to use the recharge.

But sometimes the blade is missing or of average quality.

The child safety s

It is preferable that they are present, and located at:

• From the cover, hatch or flap.

• On the blade.

• On the door.

Design

Of course, this is probably not the first thing that comes to mind, but a diaper pail is also a piece of furniture and therefore an element of decoration.

Manufacturers have also understood that parents wanted to buy models to match their interior and the atmosphere they wanted to give to the rooms where their children live.

You will therefore not have too much trouble finding products to your liking: gray and white have given way to blue, orange, green, purple, etc.

We hope this guide will help you maintain healthy air and a serene atmosphere for you and your baby. Our tip: If you have the time, talk to other parents about products that are within your budget and seem right for you. They will be able to give you their opinion on those they have already tried.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best diaper pail in USA?

We analyzed and compared 29 models of diaper pails sold in USA for nearly 50 hours, and took into account the opinions of 491 consumers. Here are the best models of the moment: Playtex Baby Genie Elite, Ubbi Steel, Dekor Mini, Dekor Plus, Tommee Tippee Simplee, Munchkin Step and Safety 1st Easy Saver. More details in our detailed comparison.

How to choose a diaper pail?

Here is what it is useful to pay attention to when choosing a diaper pail.

1. The price: Count around $ 30 to $ 40 for an entry-level or even intermediate model. Then you will find a number of great offers around $ 60. To take advantage of a high-end product that is very effective in trapping odors, it may be necessary to invest more, up to $ 90 or $ 100.

2. The material: There are three main choices:

2.1 “Standard” plastic: it may have a tendency, over the long term, to soak up bad smells, and will be used for a single child.

2.2 ABS plastic: it is more resistant and absorbs less odors. It is an interesting intermediate option.

2.3 Steel, treated with a powder: it confines odors and ensures foolproof strength.

3. Odor control procedures: The most common strategies for trapping odors are as follows:

3.1 The presence of rubber seals.

3.2 A hatch under the cover.

3.3 A deodorant disc.

3.4 A container, suitable, for example, for adding baking soda.

4. The refill mode: There are two types of diaper pails: Those that work with normal trash bags and those that work with proprietary refills. Normal trash bags are cheaper, but sometimes less spacious. In addition, they are generally less strong and more difficult to remove. For proprietary refills, you have to look at several elements:

4.1 The capacity of the refill: this is expressed in number of layers (newborn size). It often fluctuates between 150 and 300.

4.2 The scent of the refill: some refills are scented. It is a simple and very effective way to avoid bad odors.

4.3 The type of refill: the classic bag format is the most common, but there are also refills equipped with a ring. It is then easier to close them and dispose of them.

4.4 The price: find out about the price of refills before choosing your diaper pail, as it varies a lot from one manufacturer to another.

5. Capacity: This is not always clearly indicated, but when it is, it is expressed in newborn size diapers. This is the number of layers the trash can hold before it needs to be emptied. More details in our detailed buying guide.

How does a diaper pail work?

The operation of a diaper pail is simple. All you have to do is press your diaper into the space provided for this purpose, at the top of your trash can. By pushing it, it will be individually wrapped and hermetically sealed in an odor-resistant bag. It is then sufficient to close the cover. Bad odors and microbes are thus captured.

We do our best to offer you a comparison allowing you to choose the best possible diaper pail. If we missed any information or new models, please feel free to leave a comment below or send us a message.